Pick up groceries

Three days ago GTA VI was sitting at 99 on Metacritic. One day after launch the user reviews started piling in, and Kotaku counted over 2,000 negative ones on the PS5 page. As of yesterday the user score was 5.1, from nearly 10,000 ratings, against the critics’ 99. It’s not Grand Theft Auto anymore, they say. It went woke.

Set aside the usual day-one bugs and the 30fps cap I already mentioned, and the complaints are a karma system in a game about stealing and killing, romance at the center of the story, “unskippable boyfriend simulator scenes,” and no more hiring prostitutes. Kenneth Shepard, who wrote the Kotaku piece, isn’t far enough in to say whether the game is progressive, but he notes that it “incentivizes you to treat a woman like she’s a person.” That seems to be the problem.

Outside Metacritic it’s louder. Asmongold called it a “cuck simulator” because Jason buys groceries and fixes the house, per Gizmodo. Tectone went with “they made it gay.” Meanwhile the Xbox and PlayStation stores, where you have to own the game to rate it, had it at near-perfect ratings on launch day, across more than 120,000 reviews.

A photo of a TV showing a GTA VI mission prompt over the map, with Lucia's portrait: Pick up groceries. Plus one heart, Lucia will appreciate this. Buy some groceries and bring them back to the house.
The screenshot going around, captioned "Here's your Game of the Year, bro."

What they’re calling woke is what GTA has always been: satire of American culture. The radio, the ads, the TV, the politicians, the cops, the men who think they’re the main character. That lore is what I love most about the series.

I’m Chilean. I lived and worked in the US for a short while (and later, back in Chile, worked for an American company), which meant American co-workers and American friends. That gave me a first-hand glimpse of the real version of GTA, good and bad: the occasional racism from strangers, of course, alongside the love from friends. Dan Houser, who co-wrote most of the series, told GQ back in 2018 that “some of the stuff you see is straightforwardly beyond satire.”1 Having lived there, I can confirm.

But GTA is always satire, the misogyny included. I don’t think Rockstar writes a strip club because it thinks that’s how women should be treated; it writes the guy who thinks so, and makes him look like an idiot. You laugh at how stupid people can be, and somewhere in the laugh you catch a bit of yourself. Humor gets you to look at yourself without getting defensive, and maybe do a little better.

That only works if you notice it’s a joke, and people miss it in Dune too. Rachel Leishman, with Part Three out in December:

The key is recognizing that you’re not supposed to root for him.

Dune is, in her words, “a story of false prophets and the danger of a charismatic leader,” and yet people have been rooting for Paul Atreides since 1965.

GTA’s characters are a lot less subtle than a messiah riding a sandworm. GTA VI has a talk radio show, The Richard Bastion Show, an Alex Jones parody voiced by Jason Sudeikis, and according to HuffPost one of its guests sounds a lot like Nick Fuentes. There’s a Snapmatic account quoting an Andrew Tate parody. Leonida, the game’s Florida, “appears to be governed entirely by MAGA-style weirdos,” as Gizmodo puts it. You can’t make it more obvious than that without putting up a sign.

And still, the people it’s making fun of are mad that they can’t hire a prostitute.

Footnotes

  1. Quoted by Gizmodo, in the same piece. ↩